Alec wanted desperately to tell Milo that he was okay, that he wasn't in trouble, that no one was going to be angry or yell at him, but he knew that the best thing to do right now was to get this over with so Milo could move on. "Okay," he said, taking a deep breath. He set his backpack aside and pulled a folded piece of paper out of his pocket. "I wrote it down so that I wouldn't ramble." He took a shaky breath and tried to keep his voice steady as he read, his stomach queasy from nerves.
"The first thing I want to say is that I am in no way attempting to excuse myself from what I did wrong. I would like to explain myself, but I do not want to excuse myself. I was wrong to yell at you the way I did. I was wrong to act the way I did. The things I said, some of them might have been true, but none of that matters if the way I said them did you harm, which they did. I am sorry.
"I was having a bad morning that day, so I was already feeling raw when something you said hurt me a little bit more. I am not trying to say it was your fault. I am just saying that was the scenario. The truth is that I have had a problem for a while now, but I have avoided talking about it. I told myself it was to try to help not make you feel bad or to make you feel like I was picking on you, but I should have brought it up sooner. That is my fault. I should have told you sooner that there was friction and give us both a chance to maybe work through it.
"I know that it is unlikely that you mean it to come across like this, but when you consistently speak of how great your life was with your mother and how you cannot wait to leave and how there is nothing good in this town, it makes me feel as though I mean nothing to you. I don't mean that I think I should be equal to your mother, that is not what I mean. Your mother is special. She is on another level. Your mother is your world, it seems. But I wonder why can't we be a part of that world, too? A small part. A tiny amount of happiness while you wait for her to come for you again. I don't like seeing how unhappy you are, and I do not understand why you do not seem to want to allow yourself to be happy.
"Which leads to another fault of mine. While I think I understand more than you seem to think I do, I did not try to understand enough. When you and Xander first started hanging out, I saw in you two kindred gloomy spirits. I assumed, and maybe that was wrong of me, that you and he had the kind of friendship where you could tell him things and talk to him and let him understand. I thought that if he had that side of the friendship covered, then I could be the friend that tries to encourage happiness. Positivity. Or at least neutrality. I never intended to make you believe that I thought you should be happy about your circumstances and that you should smile and just find everything fine. That wasn't my intention, and I am sorry I came across that way. I only wanted you to be less sad. To have hope. I would have liked to see you happy, but even less sad would have been amazing to me. I did not take the time to listen enough to understand you. I should have listened more so that even if I did understand completely - which I don't - you would feel heard. I was making you feel stifled and ignored and I did not realize it. I am sorry for that."
He stopped and shifted a little. "I almost didn't put this part in, but I think it's kind of important so that you can understand where I am coming from, so... here it goes."
"When we were living with our mum, we went through a lot of dark times. Plenty of them. Different from yours, but still dark. There were times when Xander would get a lot angry and a little sad, and our mum would get a lot angry and a lot sad. Both of them, but especially Xander, tended to spiral into darkness and no longer see anything good or positive in life. No light, no joy, no happiness, no hope. Mum was a little okay because she had to go to work, and she had a lot of stubbornness to, as she said, 'push through it.' She would want to lay in bed and do nothing, and once in a while she would, but then she would always get up and push through because she had to, but there would still be no hope. I was the one to focus on hope. I was the one who had to be optimistic, and I had to be because if I didn't, I thought I would lose them both to the darkness forever. I thought that if I wasn't the happy one, the optimistic one, the one who always looked for a silver lining then there would be nothing for anyone to hope for. So, I worked at it. No matter how sad I was, no matter how overwhelmed I was or how much I wanted to be angry, I would shove it all aside because I needed to, not for myself, but for my family.
"When I saw you and Xander together, I think I got afraid. I couldn't see the hope in the here and now with you two. It's good to feel sadness and anger and to let yourself deal with them, which is something I still struggle with, but I was afraid you would both get stuck there in the darkness, and you both mean a lot to me. I didn't want to let you guys fade. Maybe I was wrong to do that. Maybe I was wrong to try to be your friend when you were Xander's friend, but after I started, I didn't want to let you down. I didn't want to be one of those people who 'got to know you and then left,' I think you said once. I didn't trust you enough to think you'd understand that I didn't dislike you, I just wasn't sure we were a good match friendship-wise. So, I forced my friendship on you. And I shouldn't have. I like you, Milo. I think you are an awesome, awesome guy who doesn't let himself be as awesome as he could be because you have very real and very legitimate problems holding you back, and I wanted to see you be even more awesome, but I was wrong to try to force a friendship that turned harmful to us both. I am sorry for that.
"You don't have to forgive me. Not now and not ever if you don't want to. We don't have to try to be friends if you don't want to. I just want you to know that I am sorry. You can do with that whatever you want."
Keeping his gaze lowered, Alec folded up the letter and fiddled with it before awkwardly holding it out toward Milo. "If you want it, you can have it. In cause you need to reference it. Or burn it. It might feel good to burn it if you're mad at me."